What is the Felony Murder Rule in California?

The felony murder rule has long been a controversial aspect of criminal law, sparking debates about justice, intent, and culpability. In California, recent changes to this rule have significantly altered its application and impact on criminal cases.

The Evolution of California’s Felony Murder Rule

Historically, the felony murder rule allowed prosecutors to charge a defendant with first-degree murder if a death occurred during the commission of certain felonies, even if the defendant didn’t intend to kill anyone or wasn’t directly responsible for the death.

This broad application of the rule led to situations where individuals could face murder charges for deaths they neither caused nor intended.

However, in 2018, California took a significant step in reforming this law with the passage of Senate Bill 1437. This legislation, which went into effect on January 1, 2019, substantially narrowed the scope of the felony murder rule, reflecting a growing recognition that the traditional rule could lead to unjust outcomes.

The Current Felony Murder Rule in California

Under the revised law, a person can only be convicted of felony murder if one of the following conditions is met:

1. The person was the actual killer.
2. The person, with intent to kill, aided, abetted, counseled, commanded, induced, solicited, requested, or assisted the actual killer in the commission of murder in the first degree.
3. The person was a major participant in the underlying felony and acted with reckless indifference to human life.
4. The alleged victim was a peace officer who was killed while in the course of their duties, and the defendant knew or reasonably should have known that the alleged victim was a peace officer engaged in the performance of their duties.

This change represents a significant shift from the previous law, which could hold all participants in a felony equally responsible for any deaths that occurred, regardless of their individual actions or intentions.

Key Elements of the Current Felony Murder Rule

Intent to Kill

One of the most crucial changes in the new law is the emphasis on intent. For a person to be convicted of felony murder without being the actual killer, they must have acted with the intent to kill. This is a higher bar than the previous law, which could convict someone of murder even if they had no intention of anyone being harmed.

Major Participant

The law now requires that a person be a “major participant” in the underlying felony to be charged with felony murder. This term isn’t strictly defined in the statute, allowing courts some flexibility in interpretation based on the specific circumstances of each case.

Reckless Indifference to Human Life

In addition to being a major participant, the law requires that the person acted with “reckless indifference to human life.” This means they were aware of and consciously disregarded a grave risk to human life.

Implications of the New Felony Murder Rule

Reduced Scope

The new law significantly narrows who can be charged with felony murder. This means that many individuals who might have been charged with murder under the old rule may now face lesser charges or no charges at all related to a death that occurred during the commission of a felony.

Retroactive Application

One of the most impactful aspects of SB 1437 is that it applies retroactively. This means that individuals who were convicted under the old felony murder rule may be eligible to petition for resentencing if they wouldn’t be guilty of murder under the new law. This has opened the door for potentially hundreds of inmates to seek reduced sentences or even release.

Focus on Individual Culpability

The revised law places a greater emphasis on individual actions and intentions, rather than applying a blanket rule to all participants in a felony where a death occurred. This aligns more closely with the principle of proportional justice, where the punishment fits the individual’s specific role and mental state.

Why Hiring an Attorney Matters in Felony Murder Cases

For those facing charges that might involve the felony murder rule or for those who believe they may be eligible for resentencing under the new law, skilled legal representation is crucial. The nuances of this law are complex, and its application can significantly impact the outcome of a case.

Our experienced criminal defense attorneys can:

• Analyze the specific circumstances of the case in light of the new law
• Challenge the prosecution’s evidence and arguments
• Argue for reduced charges or dismissal where appropriate
• Assist with petitions for resentencing for those convicted under the old law

The changes to California’s felony murder rule represent a significant shift in how the state approaches criminal liability in cases involving deaths during the commission of felonies. As courts continue to interpret and apply the new law, we can expect to see further refinements and potentially additional legislative adjustments.

For now, it’s clear that the new felony murder rule in California aims to create a more nuanced approach to criminal liability, focusing on individual actions and intentions rather than applying a broad, one-size-fits-all standard.

As with any significant legal change, the full impact of the revised felony murder rule will become clearer over time as more cases are adjudicated under the new standard. What’s certain is that it has already had a profound effect on many cases in California and will continue to shape the landscape of criminal law in the state for years to come.

Discuss Your Case with Our Legal Team

If you or someone you love is facing criminal charges in California, swift action is imperative. The penalties can be life altering and long lasting. Give us a call today to set up a case evaluation with one of our attorneys and learn how to best protect your freedom and future.

Too often, we see clients who “wait and see,” unsure of the legal landscape ahead, only for charges to escalate. They then find themselves backpedaling into a bad defense and an even worse lawyer. Don’t let that happen to you. Protect your freedom. Protect your future. Know your rights.

The contents of this article and blog are meant for informational and marketing purposes only and do not constitute legal advice. Viewing and/or use of the blog does not form an attorney-client relationship. No statements in this post are a guarantee, warranty, or prediction of a particular result in your case.